Topic: News Credibility

The hosts point out conflicting stories from Parkland student activist David Hogg regarding his location during the shooting. While Hogg initially claimed to be in class, a later interview suggested he rode his bike to the school after the event started to record video. The discussion focuses on the potential for "blowback" when the media elevates young activists whose stories may have inconsistencies.

The mainstream media is characterized as having a complete meltdown over the past few days, leading to a significant loss in public credibility. This period of low trust is expected to be temporary but notable for its perceived failure in objective reporting.

CBS News anchor Scott Pelley admitted in a speech that the mainstream media has suffered significant failures in accuracy, specifically citing his own incorrect reporting during the Newtown shooting. Pelley had falsely reported that Nancy Lanza was a teacher at the school, a decision he took responsibility for as managing editor.

Pew Research Center data shows a dramatic decline in the believability of major news organizations over the last decade. Only 33% of respondents believe most of what they hear on 60 Minutes, while CNN and Fox News trail at 29% and 27% respectively, with the New York Times falling to 20%.

A Gallup poll indicates that American confidence in newspapers and television news remains at historic lows. The hosts argue that the media may be intentionally discrediting itself to transition the public toward "proxy sites" and anonymous blogs that will serve as the new primary sources of information.