1:28:46 Even it'll give a lot of people good ideas. Yes, yeah, we're full of them You're right or hours worth all right what's the bove controversy? What is that okay? This is the guy that they're making a big fuss about this guy He is the Trump lawyer who helped him out in some... Well, it's all explained in these clips. But he wants to make him a member of one of the circuit courts of appeal and everybody's fighting against it and they ramrodded through the committee and the committee, the Democrats on the committee, this was when the committee walked out
1:29:22 And, and... Oh I missed all of this. This is drama! High drama how did i not catch this? Oh the walkout was the best because you had it even Jeromo and we're bitching and moaning what's his name the black guy who's always yelling screaming who did that 17-hour filibuster whose name for some reason eludes me. Yeah, Cory Booker. So Cory Booker's this is outrageous! This is outrageous and then they all left and it was a big stink because they do trying to get this guy through so let's listen to clip one President Trump helped reshape the federal courts during his first term in office, and he relied heavily on the Federalist Society in that effort which helped him zero-in on judges with a conservative originalist interpretation of the Constitution. Now the nomination's machinery is restarting and Trump's most controversial judicial nominee is only one step away from... Where is this? Who um
1:30:20 What outlet is this? NPR. So they just say Trump, they don't say President Trump anymore? They just say Trump? No that's NPR they hate Trump and I should mention they talk about the Federalist Society and Trumps not using as much as he used to and they never mentioned a reason which is Amy Coney Barrett who did you know been kind of on this fence she's not that conservative in lot of issues Yeah thats why he stopped using The Heritage Foundation because they boned him Well, it's the Federalists. It is this group here that really... I'm sorry, Federalist Society. Yeah, different. Yes they boned him. They boned him! And Trumps most controversial judicial nominee is only one step away from the federal bench. I am joined by NPR's Carrie Johnson for a look at what Emil Bovey could tell us about Trump's approach to judges in his second term. Carrie welcome Hi Juana
1:31:11 So, Gary start if you can by just telling us who Anil Bhovi is and why his nomination. I'm sorry...I-I-I'm so irritated by this. You keep hearing Anil Bhovi? I'm so irritated by this! What happens in news where you just went like okay we with us we have John C Dvorak. John tell us exactly what's going on here When did it have to become hi Amy, hi Nanny, Hi BB, Hi Tootie, Hi Snacky? Why is that? It doesn't...it just wastes my time. Start if you can by just telling us who Anil Bhovi is and why this nomination is so controversial. Well, he's got some pretty strong credentials. He graduated from Georgetown Law School did a couple of clerkships with conservative federal judges and then got a job in what might be the most prestigious U.S. Attorney's Office
1:32:03 in the entire country, in Manhattan. And of course he went on to defend Donald Trump and his various criminal cases. The White House communications director says Emil Bovee is supremely qualified and a man of integrity. He says there's nobody more capable for the US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit. At his confirmation hearing Bovee told senators that he has been misunderstood. I am not anybody's henchman. I'm not an enforcer. I'm a lawyer from a small town who never expected to be in an arena like this. It's Amal, A-M-A-L, or E-E-M-I-L what is it? I'm Amel, Emil? I like the other one yeah so this guy they make a big fuss first they give his credentials he's fine but no no because he defended Trump that's the problem
1:32:53 Yeah, here we go. and a lot going on this year, from firing prosecutors who worked on those January 6 cases to walking away from the corruption case against New York City's Mayor Eric Adams. A federal judge said the decision to drop that case smacked of a bargain where DOJ would move to dismiss the case and Mayor Adams would help advance Trump's aggressive deportation agenda
1:33:37 900 former Justice Department lawyers have urged the Senate to vote no on Amal Bovee. I spoke with Stacey Young, who spent 18 years inside the DOJ. She now runs a group that connects people there with legal and ethics advice. By voting to confirm Amal Bovee to a lifetime appointment They would be doing more than just placing someone problematic on the bench. They would be giving their stamp of approval on everything that's happened at DOJ in the last six months, and that is simply unacceptable. You know what is wrong with these people? Well my question is we've had a lot of famous AMEELs right yeah like I wasn't there shift a chef named Ameel
1:34:33 Legassi. Emil Legassi, what other famous... Emil Berliner? I'm trying to think of others but they've always pronounced it as Emil why is he now Emil which of course we all know sounds like anal yeah that's why you just answered your own question right there They're really doing this on purpose? This is horrible This whole report is horrible. Defund them! What? Oh, it's too late. Yeah... That was Emeril I'm sorry it wasn't Amel, it was Emerill. Emerill Legassi. Yeah but they said Amerill. It's Amiel. Your point is well taken they're saying anal. They are! It's an outrage. I am outraged by our national public radio.
1:35:28 Carrie, we know that President Trump appointed a whole lot of judges during his first term. So how does Bovi compare? During Trump's first term, Trump confirmed more than 200 judges with help from Senator Mitch McConnell largely relying on a list the Federalist Society helped create but Bovi is not a member of the Federalist Society he He's loyal to Trump and close to people in the White House, though. That's what worries Greg Nunziata who helped advance judicial nominees as a Republican Senate aide. He now works as executive director at Society for the Rule of Law. I think there are reasons all Americans should be concerned about judges coming to the bench with political agendas and outcome-motivated orientation to judging that should concern everybody yet you know
1:36:15 Go on X dude. No one cares about anything anymore It's all slop and by the way, Trump did 200 judges Biden did 235 in his term Yeah Well, of course they will not mention that and and all them were appointed it They're all liberals as the auto pen so it wasn't actually Biden well somebody Somebody gave instructions but yes well of course So this is bogus, but let's go and wrap it up here with a couple more. It's especially notable that President Trump is breaking with the Federalist Society because that group has been just extremely successful at stacking the federal bench with very conservative judges right?
1:36:57 That success helped culminate in a 6-3 conservative supermajority on today's Supreme Court. That effort began over a generation ago in law schools and it continued all the way through Donald Trump's first Charmin office where nominees with conservative track records were closely vetted, their writings were tracked The idea was to ensure these very conservative lawyers would stay conservative and avoid the kind of drift that, say former Justice David Souter and former Justice Sandra Day O'Connor may have represented. Right? OK well I mean given the fact that the Federalist Society has been so successful tell us why Trump soured on it.
1:37:35 the president has really been frustrated with lower court judges who ruled against him, Trump went so far as to attack Leonard Leo the longtime Federalist Society official in a social media post this year as he was losing in the lower courts. Trump called him a sleazebag. You know, yeah! The mistake these guys make is they're not really explaining what's going on. No. Dumb hicks and Texas like me I don't understand any of this and I don't care like Judge Smudge
1:38:21 Yeah, amyl nitrate. Whatever! So they get the Federalist Society... Now what gets me here and you do know what's going on What gets me here is that they're bitching and moaning about the Federalist Society in the first go-round now they're bitching and moaning that he's got them loose. Why is he doing that? That's no good You can't do that Whatever he does is bad. So this is the last clip. to shape the judiciary given the fact that these are lifetime appointments. The Senate has already confirmed Trump's first federal judge, several more are in the pipeline there are fewer judicial vacancies now than in Trump's first go-round in the White House and there is also some evidence judges may be delaying their retirement so their replacements are not picked by Trump
1:39:16 I mean, there are hundreds of federal judges. Bovi is just one person so is this confirmation really likely to make a difference in how Trump's policies fare in court? You know this is a fair point. I've been talking with experts they tell me appeals court judges sit on panels of three So any one judge it's not gonna tip the balance of power but if and when Even when the president gets a vacancy on the Supreme Court, that nominee could have a lot more influence. It's not clear Amal Bovee would be at the top of Trumps list but people in the legal community tell me they think it is a possibility. Trump has been winning a lot this year in the Supreme Court and thats ultimately where this matters. What do you mean? But what about Ted Cruz I thought he was next in line