Jamal Khashoggi Disappearance, CNN Coverage Analysis
The disappearance of journalist Jamal Khashoggi at the Saudi consulate in Istanbul is analyzed through the lens of media reporting. A CNN report by Nick Robertson details Turkish claims of audio-visual evidence documenting an assault and the moment Khashoggi's life ended. Discrepancies in the audio quality of news clips are noted, specifically how background noise vanished during mentions of political targeting against Saudi Arabia.
jamal khashoggi· saudi arabia· cnn· turkey· istanbul· nick robertson· consulate
00:00 Gore has taken it up to a new level. Adam Curry, John C. DeVora. It's Sunday, October 14th, 2018. This is your award-winning Gitmo Nation Media Assassination Episode 1077. This is no agenda. Parsing the prophets and broadcasting live from the capital of the drone star state here in downtown Austin, Tejas, in the Cludio. In the morning, everybody. I'm Adam Curry. And from northern Silicon Valley where I sit here awaiting the Zephyr. I'm John C. DeVore. It's Crackpot and Buzzkill. In the morning. Yeah, we're just never gonna have that happen. I just heard it honk. No, no, no, no. It can't be. It is only 11 after the hour. It's not early. I'm telling you, I'm hearing it honk and I think it's gonna be... Well, I mean, I can hear the honk from Emeryville, this horn they got on these things. But...
00:52 The thing is, is that we never mentioned that about four shows ago, this effort came by three hours late after the show was over. Yeah, it was, you know, I can't believe I didn't call the Austin statesman to alert them to this fact. You shouldn't. It's something they should write up. So there's three or four big news deconstruction items. We have the, actually I have the correct pronunciation, Kshakji. situation, formerly known as Khashoggi. Before you go on with that, Amy Goodman got so confused with the pronunciation she would pronounce it two ways and she did say Khashoggi is the American pronunciation. Ah, well our dude... So it's still okay and I like Khashoggi better. I like it too but our dude named Bahama did send me a note and said the official pronunciation is Khasheggi.
01:43 Who wants to make it's impossible. It's okay. I just want to make sure everyone knows that you're sneezing I had to say good news tight every time you say it. That's a microaggression man So do you have a clip of her getting confused? You have a clip of her talking about you have a bunch of clips about the Khashoggi and her talking Given some some spiel. No, I don't have I didn't make that specific clip I mean, I wouldn't mind diving right into we'll just call him Khashoggi for our show just to make it easy. I Because this is very interesting in so many different ways and there's so much obvious bullcrap out there. For example, that they unlocked this guy's Apple Watch with his fingerprint. You don't need a fingerprint. Before we go into that, he had his finger right there. Yeah, but you don't need that to unlock the Apple phone. You just don't need it. No, I know, but they could have chopped his finger off anyway, just for the fun of it. Now, yeah.
02:38 I do have one, the longest clip I have is actually, I thought was a very good CNN rap. of the Khashoggi story without all the details you're gonna bring in and I'm gonna bring in. But it's just, and I thought it was an example of, a good example of CNN actually doing their job with Nick Robertson, who's a pretty good correspondent. Behind these walls topped with razor wire, the epicenter of a spiraling crisis that threatens to engulf this whole region, one that has reverberated far beyond Turkey.
03:14 A source with knowledge of the investigation tells CNN that Turkish authorities have shared some of their evidence of Jamal Khashoggi's murder inside the consulate here with their Western intelligence allies. And some of those partners have been deeply, deeply shocked at the brutality of what they learned. The evidence, according to the CNN source via Western Intelligence, includes audio-visual information from inside the building, revealing an assault, a struggle, and the moment Khashoggi's life ends. On Friday, what appears to have been a Saudi delegation ushered quickly into the building. Mission unknown.
03:57 Prince Howard Alfaisal, one of the kingdom's most trusted figures, also visiting Turkey in an effort to tamp down tensions according to Reuters. But each new detail makes the task of containing those tensions and the fallout across the Middle East more difficult. Among the many questions still unanswered, what happened to this van? seen leaving the Saudi consulate soon after Turkish officials say Khashoggi was killed. Saudi Arabia continues to deny any involvement in Khashoggi's disappearance. Its regional allies are stepping up their support. The United Arab Emirates Minister for Foreign Affairs, Anwar Gargash, tweeting,
04:41 The repercussions of political targeting of Saudi Arabia will be dire on those who inflame it. Bahrain's foreign minister Khaled bin Ahmed complaining Saudi Arabia is the target, not the search for truth. But at the center of it all, the consulate. It was last Saturday that the consul let in the media, sheepishly opening cupboards and doors. But Turkish officials are still waiting for their investigators to be given access. And that is why the fate of Jamal Khashoggi is both a mystery and an international crisis. I really like that clip for
05:21 A couple of reasons. No, seriously, CNN has been using Richard Engels a lot, which always alerts me to a lot of bullcrap coming your way. No, actually it's MSNBC that uses him. Oh, I'm sorry, because I thought you said it was CNN. No, this is CNN. CNN doesn't you drew oh, it's MSNBC. I'm sorry. You're right. You're right So what what was interesting about this clip is when he got to the true importance of this story Which is the political ramifications with Saudi Arabia the audio went completely dead. There was no background noise It was a little you know dull kind of flat and then right back to a lot of noise and information About how the guy got killed. I have some questions
06:02 Oops, let me just bring that in here because that was that was quite interesting. These walls top with this part of the repercussions political targeting of Saudi Arabia will be gone completely dead is just talking about the repercussions on those who inflame it. Bahrain's foreign minister Khalid bin still dead complaining Saudi Arabia is the target, not the search for truth. And now back to your brain. And then we say, at the center of it all, you know, it's like, how did it happen? And of course everyone's focused on how did it happen. Apple Watch chopped into bits. It's really unimportant. It's really just another dead guy. Yeah, it's just another dead guy. You know, it's like there's lots of dead people, but...
