Thanksgiving Origins, Civil War History, and Canadian Traditions
The true history of Thanksgiving is contrasted against modern mythology, noting that the holiday was formally initiated by Abraham Lincoln during the Civil War to honor dead soldiers rather than being a continuous tradition from the 1700s. The narrative of Puritans and Native Americans dining together is described as a later re-engineering of history. The discussion briefly touches on Canadian Thanksgiving, noting its earlier date in October.
thanksgiving· abraham lincoln· civil war· harvest festival· canada· puritans
00:00 Well, hey, my voice is too fast. Appropriating the native culture of corn and broadcasting live from downtown Austin, Tejas, Capital of the Drone Star State, in the Cluedio, In the Morning, everybody. I'm Adam Curry. And from Northern Silicon Valley where it's a beautiful Thanksgiving day, the sun is shining, the turkeys are roaming around the neighborhood. It's unbelievable. I'm John C. Dvorak. It's Crackpot and Buzzkill. In the Morning. Ah, those Berkeley turkeys.
00:39 There's turkeys all over the place. Happy Thanksgiving everybody! We should be shooting them. They won't let us. Can't shoot the turkeys. Happy Thanksgiving John. Happy Thanksgiving to you and happy Thanksgiving to everybody out there. So this is... and... yes? We should reveal that this is a pre-recorded show. Yeah, I actually realized when I said broadcasting live like, it's not entirely true. Well you were live to tape. I'm live. I'm a living, I'm a live guy. That's for sure. Because, no, we're taking Thanksgiving and the day after off because nobody listens to the show on Thanksgiving. Although if they do, they're going to get a good show anyway. Yes. And they're not going to get a live show. And what they will get, as is almost customary on the No Agenda show, is an explanation of the true story of Thanksgiving.
01:33 I wasn't planning on it. Oh, you always do the story. It's like the night before Christmas book How can we have a show on Thanksgiving without you telling us the true nature of Thanksgiving? Well, I'll do the short version. Okay, ready? Yeah, it's bullshit. Oh Man, it's all the corn and and the stuffing and the turkey and they never really happened that way. Oh No, there was a couple of holidays. This is very carefully outlined on my blog. You can look up Thanksgiving Truths, which is Thanksgiving on the blog. And all the stories are there. There's two posts that discuss this. And Thanksgiving was, you know, there was a harvest festival, these different things that took place in the 16 and 1700s. But Thanksgiving really became kind of an official thing during the Civil War. And it was Thanksgiving for, you know, the thanking, you know, kind of celebrating the dead.
02:27 soldiers more than anything, and we give Thanksgiving for being alive more or less. Lincoln initiated it, then it became a national holiday over time. But it all really stemmed from these thanksgivings that were proclaimed every so often throughout American history. And the one Lincoln did seems to be the one that stuck. And so they worked it out and then they re-engineered it over time to make it seem it was something where the Indians and the Puritans, whoever, the people that were living around the 1700s in the United States, were having these yearly dinners together as if it were just like, you know,
03:08 Yeah, kind of like on the Upper East Side Manhattan. Oh, yeah, Buffy. This wasn't happening. So wait a minute. If our Thanksgiving's bullcrap, is the Canadian Thanksgiving also bullcrap? Of course it is. It's just a different date. There's this, uh, the first of November. So they, they made bull crap out of bull crap. That's even worse. You know, we didn't even celebrate the Canadian Thanksgiving on the show, which I think we missed it. Is it before ours? How can that even be? How can that be? I don't get it. It's on the first. We're number one in everything. They had to pull the rug out from under us. So they did earlier. Oh, okay. All right then.
