52:29 I did. Yeah, I saw you with all the Pope clips and like well I got one Pope clip but I wasn't going to do any Pope stuff yeah I got screwed on that deal. Yeah you did What's interesting is that we both appeared to have clipped the CBS morning show about this absolute unbelievable advertisement for the shingles vaccine. Yes, and in fact as we'll use your clips but I had a...I was gonna lead into it's probably the same ones. I don't know how much they paid for this but i think it was about a four minute spot? Well here here's what aired right before it
53:13 Shingles is a condition caused by the varicella zoster virus. Most people over the age of 50 have the virus in their body that's why the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommends that everyone over the age of fifty get the two-dose shingles vaccine so that aired before this segment it was no yes it was unbelievable Unbelievable. I have four clips as well so... They ran an actual ad, then they ran the segment to back up the ad Did you not hear Gail at one point say I've been seeing the ads? Yes no she said that in this clips I have Let's play it let's play we'll kick it off with yours number one Alright lets begin this hour with some groundbreaking new research on the shingles vaccine A South Korean study found the vaccine can lower the risk of heart disease by 23% for
54:01 eight years. The vaccine in that study was used in the US until 2018, and other research shows promising results for the new version which is used now. CBS News medical contributor Dr. Celine Gounder, editor at large for public health at KFF Health News joins us now to discuss it with you. Good morning! Hello Doctor. Break this study down for us what did they find? So they looked over two million adults in South Korea over a period of about 10 years and found that people who got older shingles vaccines, what we call Zostavax It's a live virus vaccine, an older technology. Older technology? Called the vaccine! This was always confusing to me is they're touting the benefits of this older technology that hasn't been in play for seven years but somehow they folded into this new ad, this blatant ad which came after the ad. This is the most pathetic presentation I've ever recorded
54:56 live virus vaccine, an older technology. In that population we saw a 23% reduction in their risk of cardiovascular events which is pretty significant. Wow! So they're saying focus on this newer vaccine which as you say was used until 2018 the newer vaccine does not contain a live virus. you get two doses of that one starting at age 50. With that one, we are seeing even better vaccine effectiveness and we're seeing preliminary data showing that it too has cardiovascular protective effects.
55:48 First of all, paid. Obvious bring in Celine Gounder she's been read and she's got her script they just played the ad No there is a number of moments where it is obviously scripted but this is not natural It also felt to me like this research was dug up attached to new and improved technology so that it can be put on Medicaid because it lowers your heart risk Well, it's gonna be put on Medicaid anyway. You can get a shingles vaccine if you're on Medicaid or Medicaid. Oh it's already there? Okay. Yeah these vaccines are most of them okay It's not like you know I know some couple friends of mine liberals they did whatever they were told to do Libjoes and they were up in the hills and they got the shingles shot And then they got shingles One of them did almost immediately
56:46 And it was a pain. It wasn't like, oh well you know at least it wasn't as bad. Oh it's painful! Painful? It was miserable. She never had that problem before got the shot and then had a worst case scenario type of horribly painful shingles right after the shot but was it coincidence I don't know but was it the new technology yeah course it was because this other one has not been around for seven years goodness all right clip to So I got my ology, this new technology is does that mean it's like M.R.A.? Do we know? Well they do explain it. Uh, I don't think it's MRNA but they do use a fake version of the looks like she explained in that first clip. It's not it's not live virus and say some creationist like
57:36 Kind of like, I don't know how they do it. But it doesn't sound like mRNA. So what does it mean for people who received the vaccine before? This by the way is a bunch of people... Is this clip 2? Okay. This is an inside joke, I saw the commercial! I thought I better get it right away! Oh yes! Absolutely this is your... Yeah, they're laughing about the fact that this is a bought and paid for segment. I better get one of those! That's what I did- I booked mine for next week, Gail! So what does it mean for people who received the vaccine before 2018? Well, the study we're talking about today is actually with that older vaccine but I think big picture we need to be rethinking the connection between infections and chronic disease We've had this sort of artificial line between the two And what were seeing based on this data
58:36 because of the chronic inflammation you can have from an infection like chickenpox. So, chicken pox is a kind of herpes virus and as you may know once you have a herpes virus you have it forever. Oh man that's kind of conflating things isn't it? Well the thing besides conflating things like you suggest they bring out this little factoid that once you get a herpes virus you'll have it forever so what good does the shot do You have it forever. What does the shot do? Well, I'm going to tell you... The new technology is a combination of antigen and adjuvant system that stimulates the immune system to generate strong and sustained immune response so they got hamburger helper in there
59:25 And who knows? That doesn't surprise me. Yeah, it's... Who knows what that does but the point the overall point which she made is that once you have this virus this herpes any of the herpes zoster whatever they are viruses You can't get rid of them so what does the vaccine do actually I mean What does it actually do It doesn't do anything. It makes CBS and the people hosting the show richer And in that so-called study, which they never mention what it was or even cite it. They say that it kept 23% less chance of having a heart episode and that effect lasts eight years. So eight years is okay but after eight years what happens? You're older and you're gonna have more chance than whatever it was. And then the other issue with this new vaccine
1:00:21 Shingrix, to give it a plug. You have to have two shots again one of those two shot deals. It's your booster This is the whole thing is sick. And if your immune system gets weak, you're getting older, you're stressed it can come out again and so it's causing inflammation over time in your body when you have a shingles outbreak In particular, you're having a lot of inflammation that can cause inflammation of your blood vessels blood clotting all of which could lead to heart attack dementia these other problems. So yes understanding that these things can be connected infectious disease chronic disease I think is an important message here
1:00:58 Yeah, you mentioned dementia another study showed that the same type of shingles vaccine could reduce the risk of dementia Could this change the way that we think about vaccines? Wow hey and here's the question. You ask I want you to say is that the most scripted sounding question you can imagine Yes does this change the way we think about vaccines yes? I mean because it's not just against shingles it can save your life from from all kinds of horrible things. Yeah, you mentioned dementia another study showed that the same type of shingles vaccine could reduce the risk of dementia because this changed the way that we think about vaccines? I think it should so again you know we're trying to prevent some of the risk factors that lead to chronic disease which includes chronic inflammation other such infections chronic infections hepatitis C for example has been known or HPV human papillomavirus these have been known
1:01:51 cancer again through the chronic inflammation so it's again, a false dichotomy between infectious disease and chronic disease and vaccines may be a way of preventing certain chronic diseases. So bottom line who should get it? Man we clipped exactly the same too I mean like to that right down to that and I cut off and had the same kicker at the end you have That's crazy. We both caught it, we both caught it! It was like this is an ad of epic proportion and I had the ad the actual ad Yeah, that's the real kicker. I mean this like in publishing generally speaking they make a fuss editors will make a fuss if you write anything that looks like it's an ad and they really get bent out of shape if your for example I used to write kind of generalized columns so I would talk about product like we do on the show and if somehow
1:02:50 If it sounded addy, you'd get a call. No no that wasn't the real complaint they could sound addy but if the other side of the fence If the other side of the fence got wind of what was being written, they would... if they could but they never did. You mean the ad sales being the other side? The ad sales guy finds out. They'll sell an ad right next to it! Yes! Of course they will! Because there's not dumb. And that's what those say at CBS well we knew this segment was coming up so we called the company and said you know we're talking generally about vaccines No no that's not..no it wasn't the other way around
1:03:31 The company because that's it what we're listening to is the ad and they just decided to you know to Attack it on this make it worse. Yeah, I mean if they should not run that ad It should just let this be the ad but no They had did they could these guys obviously help themselves a big spend they can't have a lot of money They can't help themselves No, they can't help themselves and this is the same thing with like I was saying with the editorial where you if you You can't help yourself. You're gonna put the ad right there It's corrupt for the for the shingrix newer vaccine in the United States Once you age 50 you should be getting to do by the way The shingrix is not like a
1:04:13 general name. It's the product name, it is the brand name. Yes, it's the brand name She's not promoting the technology she's promoting the brand name For the for the Shingrix, newer vaccine in the United States once you age 50 you should be getting two doses of that and then if you're younger and immunocompromised you should also be getting 2 doses Okay, so all you guys... See I cut it off there before and now you left in all the laughing with the gay guy whose mom is mad. Yes, well now you're gonna my mom's gonna yell at me because she doesn't like what people know my yes I'm way over. Why? Why does your mom like that? I don't know why! You are so youthful! She likes the mystery. Keep being youthful! No no it is still youthful. I think it's good to tell people look this is what it looks like. Yeah exactly. This has never run away from that question Dr. Gounder always good to see you here